Discussion:
How does one born in Canada lose Canadian citizenship?
(too old to reply)
(ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
2014-06-25 19:48:33 UTC
Permalink
Looks like that question is being submitted to the Federal courts,
enroute to the Supreme Court, again.

Another Harper law that is about to bite the dust. And the lawyer
helping to make it another loss is the same one who kept Harper's choice
for Supreme Court judge, Marc Nadon, from achieving that appointment.

Born in Canada. Stripped of Canadian citizenship. Where the hell does
that person get shipped off to?
____________________________________________________________

CBC News Posted: Jun 25, 2014

Rocco Galati launches lawsuit over Citizenship Act changes
Toronto lawyer's court documents say Governor General had no
'constitutional authority' to pass Bill C-24


Toronto lawyer Rocco Galati is suing Gov. Gen. David Johnston,
Immigration Minister Chris Alexander and Justice Minister Peter MacKay
over changes to Canada's Citizenship Act.

In documents filed Wednesday morning in Federal Court, Galati asks the
court to invalidate key provisions included in a new law that gives the
government the power to revoke the citizenship of Canadian-born citizens
convicted of "terrorism, high treason, or spying offences" if they hold
dual citizenship.

The provisions passed into law last Thursday when Bill C-24, the
government's Strengthening Canadian Citizenship Act, received royal assent.

​Galati has already successfully challenged Prime Minister Stephen
Harper’s appointment of Marc Nadon to the Supreme Court of Canada.

In the court documents filed Wednesday, Galati argues it was beyond the
Governor General's "constitutional authority" to pass Bill C-24.

The bill itself, Galati argues, goes well beyond's Parliament's own reach.

The Toronto lawyer had asked parliamentarians and the Governor General
to refer key provisions of Bill C-24 to the Supreme Court for a legal
opinion.

In a phone interview with CBC News on Wednesday, Galati said he received
a reply from the Governor General's office on June 16 simply
acknowledging the content of his original letter.

Nevertheless, Bill C-24 passed into law three days later.

"It is unconstitutional," Galati said.

Galati filed the legal challenge on behalf of a group of lawyers
including Manuel Azevedo and the Constitutional Rights Centre.


Page 3:
http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/rocco-galati-launches-lawsuit-over-citizenship-act-changes-1.2687221
Greg Carr
2014-06-25 21:01:41 UTC
Permalink
Post by (ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
Looks like that question is being submitted to the Federal courts,
enroute to the Supreme Court, again.
Another Harper law that is about to bite the dust. And the lawyer
helping to make it another loss is the same one who kept Harper's choice
for Supreme Court judge, Marc Nadon, from achieving that appointment.
Born in Canada. Stripped of Canadian citizenship. Where the hell does
that person get shipped off to?
This only applies to the ppl with dual citizenship. They get deported to
their true home if convicted of treason or terrorism charges. Personally
I would like to see dual citizenship abolished.
Post by (ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
____________________________________________________________
CBC News Posted: Jun 25, 2014
Rocco Galati launches lawsuit over Citizenship Act changes
Toronto lawyer's court documents say Governor General had no
'constitutional authority' to pass Bill C-24
Toronto lawyer Rocco Galati is suing Gov. Gen. David Johnston,
Immigration Minister Chris Alexander and Justice Minister Peter MacKay
over changes to Canada's Citizenship Act.
In documents filed Wednesday morning in Federal Court, Galati asks the
court to invalidate key provisions included in a new law that gives the
government the power to revoke the citizenship of Canadian-born citizens
convicted of "terrorism, high treason, or spying offences" if they hold
dual citizenship.
The provisions passed into law last Thursday when Bill C-24, the
government's Strengthening Canadian Citizenship Act, received royal assent.
​Galati has already successfully challenged Prime Minister Stephen
Harper’s appointment of Marc Nadon to the Supreme Court of Canada.
In the court documents filed Wednesday, Galati argues it was beyond the
Governor General's "constitutional authority" to pass Bill C-24.
The bill itself, Galati argues, goes well beyond's Parliament's own reach.
The Toronto lawyer had asked parliamentarians and the Governor General
to refer key provisions of Bill C-24 to the Supreme Court for a legal
opinion.
In a phone interview with CBC News on Wednesday, Galati said he received
a reply from the Governor General's office on June 16 simply
acknowledging the content of his original letter.
Nevertheless, Bill C-24 passed into law three days later.
"It is unconstitutional," Galati said.
Galati filed the legal challenge on behalf of a group of lawyers
including Manuel Azevedo and the Constitutional Rights Centre.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/rocco-galati-launches-lawsuit-over-citizenship-act-changes-1.2687221
--
*Read and obey the Bible*
M.I.Wakefield
2014-06-26 02:07:47 UTC
Permalink
Post by Greg Carr
Post by (ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
Looks like that question is being submitted to the Federal courts,
enroute to the Supreme Court, again.
Another Harper law that is about to bite the dust. And the lawyer
helping to make it another loss is the same one who kept Harper's choice
for Supreme Court judge, Marc Nadon, from achieving that appointment.
Born in Canada. Stripped of Canadian citizenship. Where the hell does
that person get shipped off to?
This only applies to the ppl with dual citizenship. They get deported to
their true home if convicted of treason or terrorism charges. Personally I
would like to see dual citizenship abolished.
Canada won't even let someone renounce their citizenship unless they can
prove that they would not become stateless.
Uncle Steve
2014-06-26 03:17:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by M.I.Wakefield
Post by Greg Carr
Post by (ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
Looks like that question is being submitted to the Federal courts,
enroute to the Supreme Court, again.
Another Harper law that is about to bite the dust. And the lawyer
helping to make it another loss is the same one who kept Harper's choice
for Supreme Court judge, Marc Nadon, from achieving that appointment.
Born in Canada. Stripped of Canadian citizenship. Where the hell does
that person get shipped off to?
This only applies to the ppl with dual citizenship. They get deported to
their true home if convicted of treason or terrorism charges. Personally I
would like to see dual citizenship abolished.
Canada won't even let someone renounce their citizenship unless they can
prove that they would not become stateless.
Such a comfort to those of us who have been abandoned to the savages
and the corrupt criminals, and who are de facto stateless.

But it sounds nice when you tell us how concerned Canada is over the
issue of statelesness.



Regards,

Uncle Steve
--
Do not confuse "duty" with what other people expect of you; they
are utterly different. Duty is a debt you owe to yourself to fifull
obligations you have assumed voluntarily. Paying that debt can entail
anything from years of patient work to instant willingness to die.
Difficult it may be, but the reward is self-respect.
But there is no reward for doing what other people expect of you,
and to do so is not merely difficult, but impossible. It is easier to
deal with a footpad than it is with the leech who wants "just a few
minutes of your time, please -- this won't take long." Time is your
total capital, and the minutes of your life are painfully few. If you
allow yourself to fall into the vice of agreeing to such requests,
they quickly snowball to the point where these parasites will use up
100 percent of your time -- and squawk for more!
So learn to say No -- and be rude about it when necessary.
Otherwise you will not have time to carry out your dity, or to do your
own work, and certainly no time for love and happiness. The termites
will nibble away your life and leave none of it for you.
(This rule does not mean you must not do a favor for a friend, or even
a stranger. But let the choice be /yours/. Don't do it becuause it
is "expected" of you.)
-- R.A.H. in a brief interlude of nominal lucidity and sanity,
but nevertheless evidencing subtle signs of the onset of dementia.
Nobody
2014-06-26 13:05:55 UTC
Permalink
Post by Greg Carr
Post by (ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
Looks like that question is being submitted to the Federal
courts, enroute to the Supreme Court, again.
Another Harper law that is about to bite the dust. And the lawyer
helping to make it another loss is the same one who kept Harper's
choice for Supreme Court judge, Marc Nadon, from achieving that
appointment.
Born in Canada. Stripped of Canadian citizenship. Where the hell
does that person get shipped off to?
This only applies to the ppl with dual citizenship. They get
deported to their true home if convicted of treason or terrorism
charges. Personally I would like to see dual citizenship
abolished.
As usual, Karen is confused.

____________________________________________________________
Post by Greg Carr
Post by (ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
CBC News Posted: Jun 25, 2014
Rocco Galati launches lawsuit over Citizenship Act changes
Toronto lawyer's court documents say Governor General had no
'constitutional authority' to pass Bill C-24
Toronto lawyer Rocco Galati is suing Gov. Gen. David Johnston,
Immigration Minister Chris Alexander and Justice Minister Peter
MacKay over changes to Canada's Citizenship Act.
In documents filed Wednesday morning in Federal Court, Galati
asks the court to invalidate key provisions included in a new law
that gives the government the power to revoke the citizenship of
Canadian-born citizens convicted of "terrorism, high treason, or
spying offences" if they hold dual citizenship.
The provisions passed into law last Thursday when Bill C-24, the
government's Strengthening Canadian Citizenship Act, received
royal assent.
​Galati has already successfully challenged Prime Minister
Stephen Harper’s appointment of Marc Nadon to the Supreme Court
of Canada.
In the court documents filed Wednesday, Galati argues it was
beyond the Governor General's "constitutional authority" to pass
Bill C-24.
The bill itself, Galati argues, goes well beyond's Parliament's own reach.
The Toronto lawyer had asked parliamentarians and the Governor
General to refer key provisions of Bill C-24 to the Supreme Court
for a legal opinion.
In a phone interview with CBC News on Wednesday, Galati said he
received a reply from the Governor General's office on June 16
simply acknowledging the content of his original letter.
Nevertheless, Bill C-24 passed into law three days later.
"It is unconstitutional," Galati said.
Galati filed the legal challenge on behalf of a group of lawyers
including Manuel Azevedo and the Constitutional Rights Centre.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/rocco-galati-launches-lawsuit-over
-citizenship-act-changes-1.2687221
(ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
2014-06-26 16:31:28 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nobody
Post by Greg Carr
This only applies to the ppl with dual citizenship. They get
deported to their true home if convicted of treason or terrorism
charges. Personally I would like to see dual citizenship
abolished.
As usual, Karen is confused.
As usual, the very confused support the very schizophrenic confused
'Greg Carr'.
And come out of the debate looking equally stupid.
(ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
2014-06-26 23:08:15 UTC
Permalink
Post by Greg Carr
Post by (ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
Born in Canada. Stripped of Canadian citizenship. Where the hell does
that person get shipped off to?
This only applies to the ppl with dual citizenship. They get deported to
their true home if convicted of treason or terrorism charges. Personally
I would like to see dual citizenship abolished.
Born in Canada means born in Canada. Any 'dual citizenship' is an
acquired citizenship after birth in Canada.
You cannot un-do being born in Canada.

Wikipedia says it most simply:

In general, everyone born in Canada from 1947 or later acquires Canadian
citizenship at birth. In one 2008 case, a girl born to a Ugandan mother
aboard a Northwest Airlines flight from Amsterdam to Boston was deemed a
Canadian citizen for customs' purposes because she was born over
Canada's airspace.[7]

The only exceptions concern children born to diplomats, where additional
requirements apply.

Loss of Canadian citizenship

Under current law there is no provision for involuntary loss of Canadian
citizenship except:

: naturalized Canadians can have their citizenship revoked if
convicted of fraud in relation to their citizenship application, or
their original admission to Canada as an immigrant

Dhu on Gate
2014-06-25 21:57:30 UTC
Permalink
Post by (ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
Looks like that question is being submitted to the Federal courts,
enroute to the Supreme Court, again.
Another Harper law that is about to bite the dust. And the lawyer
helping to make it another loss is the same one who kept Harper's choice
for Supreme Court judge, Marc Nadon, from achieving that appointment.
Born in Canada. Stripped of Canadian citizenship. Where the hell does
that person get shipped off to?
This is the kind of law that was passed at Nuremberg in '35.

Dhu
Post by (ಠ_ಠ)РаОса
____________________________________________________________
CBC News Posted: Jun 25, 2014
Rocco Galati launches lawsuit over Citizenship Act changes
Toronto lawyer's court documents say Governor General had no
'constitutional authority' to pass Bill C-24
Toronto lawyer Rocco Galati is suing Gov. Gen. David Johnston,
Immigration Minister Chris Alexander and Justice Minister Peter MacKay
over changes to Canada's Citizenship Act.
In documents filed Wednesday morning in Federal Court, Galati asks the
court to invalidate key provisions included in a new law that gives the
government the power to revoke the citizenship of Canadian-born citizens
convicted of "terrorism, high treason, or spying offences" if they hold
dual citizenship.
The provisions passed into law last Thursday when Bill C-24, the
government's Strengthening Canadian Citizenship Act, received royal assent.
​Galati has already successfully challenged Prime Minister Stephen
Harper’s appointment of Marc Nadon to the Supreme Court of Canada.
In the court documents filed Wednesday, Galati argues it was beyond the
Governor General's "constitutional authority" to pass Bill C-24.
The bill itself, Galati argues, goes well beyond's Parliament's own reach.
The Toronto lawyer had asked parliamentarians and the Governor General
to refer key provisions of Bill C-24 to the Supreme Court for a legal
opinion.
In a phone interview with CBC News on Wednesday, Galati said he received
a reply from the Governor General's office on June 16 simply
acknowledging the content of his original letter.
Nevertheless, Bill C-24 passed into law three days later.
"It is unconstitutional," Galati said.
Galati filed the legal challenge on behalf of a group of lawyers
including Manuel Azevedo and the Constitutional Rights Centre.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/rocco-galati-launches-lawsuit-over-citizenship-act-changes-1.2687221
--
Ne obliviscaris, vix ea nostra voco.
Loading...